| 1979 |
East-West All-Star Game |
Gary McCarthy |
| 1981 |
East-West All-Star Game |
Josh Burns, Joel Castleman |
| 1985 |
All-NESCAC |
Henry "Gus" Wilmerding |
| 1986 |
All-NESCAC |
Mark Burke |
| 1988 |
Hon. Mention All-NESCAC |
Greg Cunningham, Kevin Plummer |
|
East-West All Star Game |
Joe Bisson, Paul Deutch |
| 1989 |
All America |
Kevin Plummer |
|
All-NESCAC |
Kevin Plummer |
|
East-West All Star Game |
Kevin Plummer, Drew Simmons, Charlie Burke, Andy Ayers |
| 1990 |
All-NESCAC |
Andrew Shpiz |
| 1991 |
Div.III North-South Team |
Andrew Shpiz |
|
East-West All Star Game |
Andrew Shpiz, Eric Russman |
| 1992 |
Div. III North-South Team |
Andrew Benson |
|
All-NESCAC |
Andrew Benson |
|
East-West All Star Game |
Andrew Benson, Bruce Fougere, Greg Mahoney |
| 1994 |
All-NESCAC |
Bill Bush |
|
Second Team All New England |
Bill Bush |
|
Hon. Mention All New England |
Andy Vernon |
|
East-West All Star Game |
Bill Bush, Andy Colligan, Mike King |
| 1995 |
Alternate North-South Team |
Brent McLean |
|
East-West All Star Game |
Brent McLean, Franchot Tone, Andy Vernon |
|
Hon. Mention All New England |
Andy Vernon |
| 1996 |
East-West All Star Game |
Brian Emme, Brett Nardini |
| 1997 |
East-West All Star Game |
Seth Blumenthal, Nick Maumenee |
|
Hon. Mention All New England |
Lyle Bradley, Brian Frank |
| 1998 |
East-West All Star Game |
Brian Frank, Matt King |
|
Second Team All New England |
Matt Willams |
|
Alternate North-South All-Star Game |
Brian Frank |
| 1999 |
All America (Honorable Mention) |
Matt Williams |
|
Academic All America |
Matt Williams |
|
First Team All-NESCAC |
Matt Williams |
|
Second Team All-NESCAC |
Pete Kugeler, Brad Selig |
|
Honorable Mention All-NESCAC |
Mark Melander, Tuck Jones |
|
Second Team All New England |
Brad Selig, Pete Kugeler |
|
Hon. Mention All New England |
Mark Melander, Matt Williams |
|
East-West All Star Game |
Matt Willams, Brad Selig |
| 2000 |
East-West All Star Game |
Jeremy Barron, Jeff Boyer |
|
Honorable Mention All-NESCAC |
John Shea |
| 2001 |
NEILA Senior East-West Game |
Jonathan Lay |
| 2002 |
All-America (honorable mention) |
Gabe Duncan-Roitman, John Shea |
|
First Team All-NESCAC |
Gabe Duncan-Roitman, John Shea |
|
Second Team All-NESCAC |
Barron Butler, Ben Winston |
| 2003 |
First Team All-NESCAC |
Ben Winston |
| 2004 |
Second Team All-NESCAC |
Josh Cleaver |
| 2006 |
ESPN District I All-Academic |
Kyle Haskett |
| 2007 |
Second Team All-NESCAC |
Caddy Brooks |
|
Second Team All-New England |
Caddy Brooks, Drew Piekarski |
|
NEILA Senior East-West Game |
Dana McNally, Drew Piekarski |
| 2009 |
All-America Team (honorable ment.) |
Craig Bunker |
|
First Team All-NESCAC |
Craig Bunker |
|
Second Team All-NESCAC |
Whit McCarthy |
|
USILA North-South Senior Game |
Caddy Brooks |
| 2010 |
All-America (third team) |
Craig Bunker |
|
All-America (honorable mention) |
Whit McCarthy |
|
First Team All-NESCAC |
Craig Bunker, Whit McCarthy |
|
Rookie of the Year All-NESCAC |
Ian Deveau |
|
First Team All-New England |
Craig Bunker |
|
Second Team All-New England |
Whit McCarthy |
|
Rookie of the Year All-New England |
Ian Deveau |
|
NEILA East-West Senior Game |
Whit McCarthy |
| 2011 |
All-America (first team) |
Craig Bunker |
|
USILA D3 Specialty Player of Year |
Craig Bunker |
|
First Team All-New England |
Craig Bunker |
|
Second Team All-New England |
Ian Deveau |
|
First Team All-NESCAC |
Craig Bunker |
|
Second Team All-NESCAC |
Ian Deveau |
|
USILA North/South Senior Game |
Chris Healy |
|
USILA North/South Senior Game |
Mark Squicciarino |
|
USILA North/South Senior Game |
Craig Bunker |
|
NEILA Senior All-Star Game |
Mark Squicciarino, Chris Healy, Craig Bunker |
| 2012 |
All-America (second team) |
Ian Deveau |
|
First Team All-New England |
Ian Deveau |
|
Second Team All-New England |
John Jennings, Jonathan McIvor, Bjorn Knutson |
|
First Team All-NESCAC |
Ian Deveau |
|
Second Team All-NESCAC |
John Jennings, Jonathan McIvor |
|
USILA North/South Senior Game |
Jonathan McIvor |
| 2013 |
|
All-America (first team) |
Ian Deveau |
|
All-America (honorable mention) |
John Jennings |
|
First Team All-New England |
Ian Deveau |
|
Second Team All-New England |
John Jennings, Peter Willauer |
|
NESCAC Player of the Year |
Ian Deveau |
|
First Team All-NESCAC |
Ian Deveau |
|
Second Team All-NESCAC |
John Jennings |
| 2014 |
NESCAC Rookie of the Year |
Austin Sayre |
|
NEILA Senior All-Academic Team |
Russ Wilson |
| 2015 |
All-America (honorable mention) |
Tyler Will, Derek Youngman, Austin Sayre |
|
All-New England Division III |
Tyler Will |
|
Second Team All-NESCAC |
Austin Sayre |
|
USILA North-South Senior Game |
Tyler Will |
|
NEILA East-West Senior Game |
Tyler Will, Derek Youngman, Mark Philipps |
|
NEILA Senior All-Academic Team |
John Grimaldi, Mark Philipps |
| 2016 |
NEILA Senior All-Star Game |
Sam Wasserman |
|
NEILA Senior All-Academic Team |
Sam Wasserman, Kenny Jacobson |
| 2017 |
Second Team All-NESCAC |
C.J. Layton |
|
NEILA Senior All-Academic Team |
Austin Sayre |
| 2018 |
Second Team All-NESCAC |
C.J. Layton |
|
NEILA Senior All-Academic Team |
Tucker Dietrick |
| 2019 |
First Team All-NESCAC |
C.J Layton |
| 2021 |
Second Team All-NESCAC |
Jack Rickards |
|
Second Team All-NESCAC |
Noah Froio |
|
Second Team All-NESCAC |
Will Dodge |
| 2022 |
Second Team All-NESCAC |
Jack Rickards |
